Ontario Court of Appeal keeps Canadian publishers' case against OpenAI in Canada
On 13 November 2026 the Ontario Court of Appeal dismissed OpenAI's appeal of a lower-court ruling and held that Ontario courts have jurisdiction over a copyright lawsuit brought by a coalition of Canadian news organisations, including CBC/Radio-Canada, Torstar, Postmedia, The Globe and Mail and The Canadian Press. The publishers, who filed the suit in 2025, allege that OpenAI used their journalism to train ChatGPT without permission or compensation. OpenAI had argued the dispute belonged in a United States court. The ruling resolves jurisdiction only; the merits remain to be tried.
Why It Mattered
The jurisdictional question decided here is more consequential than it appears, because it determines which copyright regime governs model training. A case tried in Ontario is decided under Canadian fair dealing, which is a closed list of enumerated purposes, rather than the open-ended United States fair use standard on which the leading American rulings about training data have turned. Developers had argued, in substance, that training takes place where the servers are and should be judged by the law of that place; this ruling rejects that framing for Canada and ties liability to where the publishers and their market sit. If other jurisdictions follow, the practical consequence is that a single training run is exposed to the most restrictive national copyright rule among the markets a model is offered in, rather than to the law of the developer's home country. That changes the economics of data acquisition more than any individual damages award would. The decision also keeps alive the largest coordinated action by news publishers outside the United States at a moment when the American litigation had produced mixed outcomes, including the dismissal of publisher antitrust claims over AI search summaries earlier in 2026. For a 2030 history, this is one of the points at which the territorial reach of AI training liability began to be settled, and it is a reminder that the decisive rulings in the AI copyright wars were often procedural rather than substantive.
Who Built It
Ontario Court of Appeal
Applications
- Copyright Law
- News Publishing
- Model Training Data